What
Does It Mean to be Well Educated?
Kohn
poses an intriguing question. Our society
has long valued an exceptional education as an autonomic acceptance among other
people. But why this is so is question that
has a variety of answers. And these
answers will differentiate among different people with different walks of life.
In
the first chapter, Kohn dances around several factors that prove to be important
in education, but he concludes with the thoughts from Dewey “To be well
educated, then, is to have the desire as well as the means to make sure that
learning never ends.” I very much agree
with Dewey in this aspect. I see one of
the central purposes of schooling is to not only educate the students, but
instill in them an intrinsic motivation to further their education. This will impose a hunger and ambition in the
students to form their own inquiries and have the means to seek their own
answers. The continuum of learning compelled
by education will equip the students with a set of problem-solving skills that
will be very useful for success in life.
This
concept of the necessity of education may be widely accepted, but the means of
this education varies. Kohn discusses
the different types and methods of schooling, addressing how each type can be
beneficial and detrimental. For example,
Kohn discloses his opinion on private schooling. I have always viewed private schooling as a
more privileged education, providing more opportunities for success for their
students. But Kohn explains the leeway
that private schools hold and how it can actually be detrimental to a student’s
success if he falls below standards.
Private schools are not as accepting of students with lower social class
or those with strong opinions differing from those of their own. Consider a student with a learning disability. How would he fit in in a private school? If this school is not receiving public
funding, will this child be able to be appropriately aided in a public school
setting?
In
chapter nine, Kohn also discusses his stance on grading in a school
system. He is a strong stakeholder in
the idea of a school system barren of grades.
I find this topic interesting, especially with the resounding reasons he
gives as to why he feels this way. Kohn
describes grades as imposing a competition among the students. Creating such a competitive environment in a
classroom can lead to restrictive learning in some students. Such a competitive environment can even spoil
students’ relationships with one another.
I have seen this happen from my own experience. When I was in grade school, I was in a
constant competition with another girl in my class to get the higher
grade. We were even co-captains of the
scholar bowl team. We were once fighting
over a question during a meet about how to spell the word “thesaurus.” I insisted the correct spelling, while she
was sure that she had the correct spelling.
When she submitted her answer and got it wrong, she stormed out of the
meet crying. Such pressure on a student
can create a thick and restraining atmosphere in school.
Overall
Kohn’s views on education proved to be interesting to me. He introduced a variety of topics that had
never occurred to me, and opened my mind to more aspects that I will inevitably
encounter as a future educator.
No comments:
Post a Comment